top of page

F&I agent and dealership manager discussing compliance strategies in a car dealership showroom, highlighting proactive measures and collaboration for adherence to the FTC's CARS Rule.

At Agent Summit 2024, James Ganther, Esq. delivered a powerful speech dissecting the implications of the Federal Trade Commission’s (FTC) CARS Rule. This blog post will explore Ganther's key insights and provide actionable strategies for dealerships to stay compliant.


WATCH THE FULL KEYNOTE:


Key Takeaways from Ganther's Speech


Challenging the CARS Rule’s Portrayal of the Industry

Ganther argued that the CARS Rule unjustly portrays the auto retail industry as inherently deceptive. He emphasized that most dealerships are dedicated to serving customers honestly and ethically.


Redundancy in Fraud Regulations

Ganther pointed out that fraud is already illegal, questioning the necessity of the CARS Rule. He suggested that adding more regulations could create unnecessary complexity without significantly enhancing consumer protection.


Practical Challenges with Pricing Disclosures

The rule’s requirement for clear and conspicuous pricing disclosures poses practical challenges. Ganther highlighted the difficulties dealerships might face in implementing these requirements, which could lead to consumer confusion rather than clarity.


Ambiguities in the Rule’s Language

Ganther criticized the rule’s ambiguous language and terminology, calling for clearer and more precise regulatory guidelines to ensure fair enforcement.


Implications of the CARS Rule for Dealerships


Transparency in Advertising

The CARS Rule mandates transparent advertising practices, requiring dealerships to disclose the full price of vehicles, excluding only required government charges. This aims to eliminate bait-and-switch tactics and hidden fees, promoting a fairer marketplace.


Website Compliance

Dealership websites must adhere to the rule’s advertising disclosure requirements. Ensuring compliance across digital platforms will be crucial, as non-compliance could result in significant fines.


Dealer Fees and Add-Ons

The rule prohibits charging for add-ons that do not provide a benefit to consumers. Dealerships must review their fee structures and ensure all add-ons are genuinely valuable and clearly disclosed.


Clear and Conspicuous Disclosures

Dealerships must implement clear and conspicuous disclosures in all advertising. This includes both visual and audible disclosures, ensuring that consumers fully understand the terms of the transaction.


Navigating Compliance


Proactive Measures

Dealerships should take proactive steps to ensure compliance. This includes staying informed about regulatory updates, regularly reviewing advertising practices, and updating contracts and policies.


Strategic Partnerships

Partnering with knowledgeable agents and compliance experts can provide invaluable support. These partners can offer training, resources, and ongoing guidance to help dealerships navigate the evolving regulatory landscape.


Empowering Agents as Compliance Allies

Agents play a vital role in supporting dealerships through regulatory changes. They can help by:

  • Staying informed through industry events and updates.

  • Educating dealers about the CARS Rule and providing resources like recorded presentations.

  • Preparing for compliance by developing policy templates, training materials, and website review processes.

  • Offering support by helping dealerships find specialized compliance vendors and navigate the evolving landscape.


Conclusion

The automotive compliance landscape is constantly evolving. The FTC’s CARS Rule introduces significant changes that dealerships must adapt to. By staying informed and proactive, dealerships can not only ensure compliance but also build trust with consumers through transparency and honesty.


Watch the Full Video for More Insights

For a deeper understanding of the CARS Rule and its implications, watch James Ganther’s full keynote address at Agent Summit 2024.


Stay Updated on Automotive Compliance

Subscribe to our blog for ongoing discussions on the CARS Rule, automotive compliance updates, and industry best practices. Follow us on LinkedIn to join the conversation and stay ahead of the curve. Let's navigate the world of automotive commerce together!






More About the CARS Rule:

This year, at the Agent Summit 2024 held at the Cosmopolitan Hotel and Casino in Las Vegas, the finance and insurance (F&I) industry celebrated a momentous occasion—the first-ever induction into the F&I Hall of Fame. The inductees, Larry Dorfman, Arden Hetland, and David Robertson are pioneers whose contributions have shaped the landscape of automotive finance and insurance.



F&I Hall of Fame Inductees


Larry Dorfman, known for his passion and dedication, founded APCO Holdings Inc. - EasyCare in 1984, building it into a cornerstone of the F&I landscape. Describing himself as an "agent at heart," Dorfman's vision and leadership have been central to the company’s success and its role in enhancing customer service and satisfaction across the industry.


Arden Hetland was president and CEO of American Financial & Automotive Services and American Financial Warranty Corp. A founding member of the Association of Finance and Insurance Professionals, Hetland has left an indelible mark on the profession.


David Robertson began his automotive career as a car salesman in 1971 and moved up the ranks to become a founding member and chairman of the Association of Finance & Insurance Professionals. His extensive experience and leadership in founding or leading several companies continue to influence the industry as he serves as a consultant.


A Legacy of Integrity and Excellence

The F&I Hall of Fame ceremony was not just a recognition of past achievements but a celebration of the enduring values that these pioneers have instilled in the business. Tony Wanderon, CEO of APCO Holdings, highlighted that these inductees are exemplary models of conducting business with integrity and commitment. Ron Reahard, president of Reahard & Associates, commended their consistent efforts to improve the industry.


Mosaic Compliance Services' James S. Ganther, Esq., was a member of the selection committee. Mosaic's partnership with APCO and American Financial, spearheaded by Dorfman and Hetland, brought top-tier compliance training to dealerships nationwide. From 2016 to 2021, American Financial won the Dealers' Choice Diamond Award for Compliance Training.


As we celebrate these trailblazers, we also look forward to the continued advancement of the F&I industry. Their legacies, characterized by a commitment to excellence and ethical practices, set a high standard for future leaders. At Mosaic Compliance Services, we remain committed to fostering these values through our training programs, ensuring that the industry grows and does so with integrity and respect for all stakeholders.



Attention car dealerships: If your business handles sensitive customer information, it's crucial to understand the new requirements under the FTC’s Gramm-Leach Bliley Safeguards Rule. As of May 13, 2024, an amendment mandates reporting certain data breaches and security events to the FTC. Here's what you need to know to stay compliant and protect your customers.


Thumbnail image showing a secure digital lock symbol over a background of various car dealership documents and symbols related to the automotive retail industry, representing data protection and compliance with the FTC Safeguards Rule. The design is professional and clean, with a blue color scheme evoking trust and security.

Understanding the Safeguards Rule:


The Safeguards Rule is designed to ensure businesses protect the security and confidentiality of nonpublic personal information. The FTC has updated this rule to keep pace with technological advancements and current security challenges. For car dealerships, this means new obligations to report data breaches affecting customer information.


Who Needs to Comply?


Car dealerships fall under the category of financial institutions subject to the FTC’s jurisdiction. This broad definition includes any business handling customer financing details, loan applications, or other personal financial information. Your dealership is likely covered if you deal with this type of data.


New Safeguards Rule Notification Requirements:


As of Monday, May 13, 2024 car dealerships must comply with the Safeguards Rule notification requirement. Dealers must report to the FTC within 30 days of discovering a security breach affecting 500 or more consumers. A breach is defined as unauthorized access to unencrypted customer information, or when an unauthorized person obtains the encryption key. Read more about the notification requirements going into effect here.


How to Report:


The FTC has made the reporting process straightforward. Use their new online form, which clearly outlines the information required:

  • Name of the affected dealership

  • Contact person details

  • Start and end dates of the breach

  • Number of consumers affected

  • Types of information involved

  • Summary of the breach event

  • Law enforcement delay requests (if applicable)


Access the form here.


Ensuring Compliance:


While the Safeguards Rule is essential, it’s not a substitute for other federal and state regulations. Make sure your dealership meets all relevant legal obligations to protect consumer information effectively. Regularly review your data protection policies and update them as needed to stay compliant and secure.


Staying ahead of regulatory changes is critical for car dealerships. By understanding and complying with these rules, you can help ensure your dealership's continued success.



bottom of page